Canyon County sheriff: Triple homicide suspect Mike Bullinger likely dead


CALDWELL, Idaho (KBOI) — Over six months ago, news of a gruesome triple murder in Caldwell shocked the Treasure Valley.

While time has passed, others aren’t letting the memory of the victims, 56-year-old Cheryl Baker, 48-year-old Nadja Medley and 14-year-old Payton Medley fade.

Today, Canyon County’s sheriff fears the man he thinks is responsible will never be brought to justice.

All evidence might indicate he’s dead.

“This isn’t a closed case whatsoever,” sheriff Kieran Donahue told KBOI 2News on Thursday. “It’s a very open, very active case.”

It’s an active case that’s focused on finding answers.

The scene at the triple homicide, located on KCID Road near Highway 20/26, was so gruesome, the sheriff says it still bothers him today.

“One of the deputies was able to determine…basically a smell coming from that shed,” he said. “Upon further investigation…we find

Read more at:

Leave a Reply